Why Shelfari.com sucks so much!

September 4th, 2007 by Prateek Dayal | Print Why Shelfari.com sucks so much!

Generally I am not the kinds who write about a product or service on my blog and say bad things about it. But then I have to say this …

The website Shelfari.com is a new service to let people talk about the books that they have read etc and I think that is a great idea. However what sucks is the cheap tricks they pull off to get people to signup. You have an option to import your gmail contacts (like other websites) and in itself nothing bad about it. However it shows you two lists, one below each other. The list on the top is people who are a member of shelfari already (a few) and then a invite button and the list below that is a list of people who are not member of shelfari (a few hundred may be if you use gmail etc that stores all addresses) and an invite button below this list. By default all the contact are checked (shelfari/non-shelfari). Most likely you would never have the strength to uncheck so many (A better behaviour that even linked-in does is to have everything unchecked by default)

Any sensible guy would assume that clicking on the button below shelfari members list would invite them and clicking below the non-shelfari members would invite them. However I clicked the button to connect with friends on shelfari and the invitation went even to members who are not on shelfari (about 600 in my case). Not this is some serious serious SPAM. Also after a few days a ‘gentle reminder’ goes to everyone who has still not joined (They write a disclaimer on the invite page, I later saw that you will never read or misunderstand)

I feel as a web 2.0 company this is some really bad practice …. users are used to certain ways and you should not try to take advantage of them and put little gotchas that work for you …. I just wonder if shelfari can bring in real active users like this to their website .. I am surely never gonna use the site again …

I hope in the near future, Shelfari would take care of that .. Goodluck to them and be careful before you hit invite!

Popularity: 100% [?]

 
  • http://nonstopgoli.blogspot.com Goli

    Hey
    I have not much explored Shefari or whatever that is, but I did really loved the way you put this blog. I think that was very honest feedback which even Shefari guys would love to read it.

  • http://nonstopgoli.blogspot.com Goli

    Hey
    I have not much explored Shefari or whatever that is, but I did really loved the way you put this blog. I think that was very honest feedback which even Shefari guys would love to read it.

  • http://thoughtsprevail.blogspot.com HIMANSHU SHETH

    Hey Prateek,
    I agree with you.Even I joined Shelfari and after joining it, doing the things that you have mentioned was a pain.This would be more painful to people who don’t use Internet to the fullest.

    Importing contacts from Gmail,Yahoo and other mail services is common and work very well in case of LinkedIn but in this case ,it is horrible.

    One other irritating thing is the widget that you can put on the blog/site,which is also very ugly and I am sure that most of people would not prefer to put that widget on their blogs (:

    On important thing,you missed out:
    Shelfari is supported by Amazon and still the site is not good.

    Shelfari was officially launched in October 2006 with Josh Hug and Kevin Beukelman as the co-founders., Amazon.com invested in Shelfari in February 2007 and Shelfari immediately formed a board of advisors combing a list of high profile individuals. For further information on Shelfari, check out the featured links on the left hand side.

    This is one of the classic examples of how a big brand name can create so much hype though the services are not good :)

    -Himanshu Sheth

  • http://thoughtsprevail.blogspot.com HIMANSHU SHETH

    Hey Prateek,
    I agree with you.Even I joined Shelfari and after joining it, doing the things that you have mentioned was a pain.This would be more painful to people who don’t use Internet to the fullest.

    Importing contacts from Gmail,Yahoo and other mail services is common and work very well in case of LinkedIn but in this case ,it is horrible.

    One other irritating thing is the widget that you can put on the blog/site,which is also very ugly and I am sure that most of people would not prefer to put that widget on their blogs (:

    On important thing,you missed out:
    Shelfari is supported by Amazon and still the site is not good.

    Shelfari was officially launched in October 2006 with Josh Hug and Kevin Beukelman as the co-founders., Amazon.com invested in Shelfari in February 2007 and Shelfari immediately formed a board of advisors combing a list of high profile individuals. For further information on Shelfari, check out the featured links on the left hand side.

    This is one of the classic examples of how a big brand name can create so much hype though the services are not good :)

    -Himanshu Sheth

  • http://www.planetmike.com/journal/2007/10/23/shelfaricom-spam/ Michael Boyd Clark Journal/Blog

    Shelfari.com Spam…

    If you’re new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!The latest attempt to get into people’s webmail accounts is from a group Shelfari. Apparently set up as a service to help your friends learn about new books to re…

  • http://blog.labnotes.org/2007/11/20/rounded-corners-167-all-talk-no-ads/ Labnotes » Rounded Corners – 167 (All talk, no ads)

    [...] careful out there. Today’s Web 2.0 spammer: Shelfari. Another Web 2.0 social-something-something site with so little confidence in their own stuff, they [...]

  • gedang

    thanks for your comment on shelfari, like you i thought the site very exciting until it started giving me problems, That was an excellent and gentle comment, I just hope that big brands like amazon should not collaborate with such company, many thanks again and goodbye shelfari, for the moment

  • http://noneyet gedang

    thanks for your comment on shelfari, like you i thought the site very exciting until it started giving me problems, That was an excellent and gentle comment, I just hope that big brands like amazon should not collaborate with such company, many thanks again and goodbye shelfari, for the moment

  • http://boyarul.blogspot.com boyarul

    Dude, when I’m signing up to this kind of sites, I never use that invitation “feature”. Always try to avoid that. Cheers!

  • http://boyarul.blogspot.com boyarul

    Dude, when I’m signing up to this kind of sites, I never use that invitation “feature”. Always try to avoid that. Cheers!

  • http://brants.wordpress.com manuscrypts

    the repeat invitation is very annoying, especially when they don’t even bother to check if you’re an existing member!! I find it much easier to use the visual bookshelf on fb… the only reason i even checked that out was because shelfari’s fb application just refused to work initially…

  • http://brants.wordpress.com manuscrypts

    the repeat invitation is very annoying, especially when they don’t even bother to check if you’re an existing member!! I find it much easier to use the visual bookshelf on fb… the only reason i even checked that out was because shelfari’s fb application just refused to work initially…

  • Seth Tiffany

    I don’t really agree with you on this! Each time i login on to shelfari.com i love it. Each person has a voice and each person is heard. I can see someways on it being bad but alot of it is good! Not every thing about it is bad! have a nice day!

  • Seth Tiffany

    I don’t really agree with you on this! Each time i login on to shelfari.com i love it. Each person has a voice and each person is heard. I can see someways on it being bad but alot of it is good! Not every thing about it is bad! have a nice day!

  • Ms. Dixit

    I think u r over reacting… Keep CooL.. wats wrong if they wish more n more ppl to come across their product..Marketing is a imp strategy

  • Ms. Dixit

    I think u r over reacting… Keep CooL.. wats wrong if they wish more n more ppl to come across their product..Marketing is a imp strategy

  • Ryan

    I was banned from Shelfari for politely disagreeing about the historical accuracy of “The Book of Mormon”. They were mad that I pointed out flaws in its history and so they contacted an admin, Amanda, and she banned me just because they had the majority. She said my comments were inflamatory but they were much more polite than what was being written to and about me.

  • Ryan

    I was banned from Shelfari for politely disagreeing about the historical accuracy of “The Book of Mormon”. They were mad that I pointed out flaws in its history and so they contacted an admin, Amanda, and she banned me just because they had the majority. She said my comments were inflamatory but they were much more polite than what was being written to and about me.

  • Yazka

    well i dont think it sucks.. shelfari is great
    i am a member there and its the best

  • Yazka

    well i dont think it sucks.. shelfari is great
    i am a member there and its the best

  • http://godkillzyou.wordpress.com David

    It might not suck if a didn’t perpetually get the “shelf failed to load” message every single moment of every day.

  • http://godkillzyou.wordpress.com David

    It might not suck if a didn’t perpetually get the “shelf failed to load” message every single moment of every day.

  • http://edwardkhoo.com/shelfari-com-social-network-for-book-lovers/ Shelfari.com | Social Network for Book Lovers

    [...] pay attention, everyone in your contact list might ended up receiving invitation from you. (Source #1 & [...]

  • http://blogs.mazdarulezzz.ru Nice

    what a nice story..

  • http://blogs.mazdarulezzz.ru Nice

    what a nice story..

  • Read the fine print

    …it would make sense not to hit the invite button and personally email who you want to show/join. That’s pretty much the deal with every site, not just Shelfari.

  • Read the fine print

    …it would make sense not to hit the invite button and personally email who you want to show/join. That’s pretty much the deal with every site, not just Shelfari.

  • http://nagpai.blogspot.com Nagesh Pai

    A similar experience i had for the first time was with Hi5, after which i never logged into the site again.

    Its ironic that these sites are called “social” networking when they do not follow the basics of a sane society

  • http://nagpai.blogspot.com Nagesh Pai

    A similar experience i had for the first time was with Hi5, after which i never logged into the site again.

    Its ironic that these sites are called “social” networking when they do not follow the basics of a sane society

  • http://www.shelfari.com/debasismandal Debasis

    One can skip the invition step.

  • http://www.shelfari.com/debasismandal Debasis

    One can skip the invition step.

  • http://allzoom.ru.ru Zashkaser

    Your blog was of course amazing again even though it was terrifying for me to read what happened to you.You turned what could have been a very bad thing into something funny and positive. Do take care. Also your live radio news broadcast was also amazing.I love you xoxox

  • http://allzoom.ru.ru Zashkaser

    Your blog was of course amazing again even though it was terrifying for me to read what happened to you.You turned what could have been a very bad thing into something funny and positive. Do take care. Also your live radio news broadcast was also amazing.I love you xoxox

  • http://google.com/874 sandra407

    Hi! I was surfing and found your blog post… nice! I love your blog. :) Cheers! Sandra. R.

  • http://google.com/874 sandra407

    Hi! I was surfing and found your blog post… nice! I love your blog. :) Cheers! Sandra. R.

  • http://www.medunivers.com/ viagra
  • http://www.medunivers.com/ viagra
  • http://amyl.pl/loan loan

    cool nice site

  • http://amyl.pl/loan loan

    cool nice site

  • warez dll

    Your blog was of course amazing again even though it was terrifying for me to read what

  • http://maniac-ddl.comhttp:// warez dll

    Your blog was of course amazing again even though it was terrifying for me to read what

  • http://www.intermost.ru Перевозка грузов

    Nice Post! More like that!

  • http://www.intermost.ru Перевозка грузов

    Nice Post! More like that!

  • http://www.free-poker-play.mp Poker

    If you want to play poker for free you might find this useful.

  • http://www.free-poker-play.mp Poker

    If you want to play poker for free you might find this useful.

  • http://alpromtlt.ru excelvick

    блог прекрасный. успеха в работе

  • http://alpromtlt.ru excelvick

    блог прекрасный. успеха в работе

  • http://networking.bizjournals.com/post/mark4386/blog/getting_the_advantages_of_toll_free_numbers.html Cool Template

    Hey, I come across this site by on a fluke when I was exploring on Google then I came upon your site. I have to say your web site is very cool I like your theme! At this moment I don

  • http://networking.bizjournals.com/post/mark4386/blog/getting_the_advantages_of_toll_free_numbers.html Cool Template

    Hey, I come across this site by on a fluke when I was exploring on Google then I came upon your site. I have to say your web site is very cool I like your theme! At this moment I don

  • asad

    this is a great article! fotograf zdjecia slubne and fotografia slubna bielsko Katowice krakow fine art. Psycholog on Line korzysci pomocy online fotografia dziecieca zdjecia dzieci, fotograf slubny fotografia dzieci depresja stres psycholog i pomoc psychologiczna pomoc psychologa and internetowy psycholog psychologia internetowa poradnia psychologiczna and Psychologia and psycholog online psycholog on-line pomoc psychologiczna przez Internet and psycholog online psycholog internetowy and psycholog przez internet

  • asad

    this is a great article! fotograf zdjecia slubne and fotografia slubna bielsko Katowice krakow fine art. Psycholog on Line korzysci pomocy online fotografia dziecieca zdjecia dzieci, fotograf slubny fotografia dzieci depresja stres psycholog i pomoc psychologiczna pomoc psychologa and internetowy psycholog psychologia internetowa poradnia psychologiczna and Psychologia and psycholog online psycholog on-line pomoc psychologiczna przez Internet and psycholog online psycholog internetowy and psycholog przez internet

  • http://www.letrav.ru TriadaSoani

    А как на блоге можно заработать? У меня есть блог о игре на гитаре. Правда там народа в день не много ходит…человек 20. Можно с него что то заработать?

  • http://www.letrav.ru TriadaSoani

    А как на блоге можно заработать? У меня есть блог о игре на гитаре. Правда там народа в день не много ходит…человек 20. Можно с него что то заработать?

  • http://www.kamieniarstwo-nagrobki.eu Nagrobki

    Thats the cool’s themes i have see in a long time.
    Very nice

  • http://www.kamieniarstwo-nagrobki.eu Nagrobki

    Thats the cool’s themes i have see in a long time.
    Very nice

  • http://www.anremmash.ru TriadaSoani

    Хорошо написал. Так держать!!! :)

  • http://www.anremmash.ru TriadaSoani

    Хорошо написал. Так держать!!! :)

  • http://www.esteren.ru TriadaSoani

    А у Вас талант писателя прям :)

  • http://www.esteren.ru TriadaSoani

    А у Вас талант писателя прям :)

  • http://www.denjek.ru TriadaSoani

    Хороший блог. Занёс в букмарки

  • http://www.denjek.ru TriadaSoani

    Хороший блог. Занёс в букмарки

  • http://wwww.onet12.pl Carkittimbict

    Super nowy test Loksphono Super nowy test Loksphono Super nowy test Loksphono Super nowy test Loksphono Super nowy test Loksphono Super nowy test Loksphono Super nowy test Loksphono

  • http://wwww.onet12.pl Carkittimbict

    Super nowy test Loksphono Super nowy test Loksphono Super nowy test Loksphono Super nowy test Loksphono Super nowy test Loksphono Super nowy test Loksphono Super nowy test Loksphono

  • http://coolmaiki.ru/ модные женские футболки

    ок ну раздули тут полемику

  • http://coolmaiki.ru/ модные женские футболки

    ок ну раздули тут полемику

  • http://www.windingpathcreations.com/index.php loely online

    Hey I like the of the posts. Bye now

  • http://www.windingpathcreations.com/index.php loely online

    Hey I like the of the posts. Bye now

  • http://iservepharmacy.com/ generic viagra

    I would like to have a blog to comment about books I have read with my friends and even with people I do not know !!! It is disappointing to know that some people take advantage of this type of blogs to make some money beause it should not be the intentation

  • Kasongroup005

    I don’t usually comment on blogs, but I had to on yours. I love the little gravatar dudes! Great post!

  • http://www.worldoftrade.com/sell/rolex-jewelry.htm Rolex Jewelry

    Thank you a lot for the news just about Review launches! That is obviously that the essay writing services can make the custom essay writing. Thus, it’s a very good opportunity to buy papers and custom written essays referring to Review launches.

  • http://www.affordablewriting.net/essay-writing.html Essay Writing

    This news is very cool, I like it very much but can you post a newer news?

    Good post and a fantastic read.

  • http://www.realpharmacyrx.net/ viagra Generic

    While launching any of the website with a complete unique theme would require lots of efforts in testing the technicalities. However, with this particular website it seems huge corrections to be done in order to make it free flowing and match the requirements of users.

  • http://www.rapidwriters.net/ Writing Essay Services

    Great information thanks for sharing this with us.In fact in all posts of this blog their is something to learn. your work is very good and i appreciate your work and hopping for some more informative posts. Again thanks

  • Anonymous

    this is really nice blog here
    thank you
    generic viagra

  • Anonymous

    Its really useful Post. Thank you for the nice Post.
    buy generic viagra

  • http://www.mee4slend.com/ อยากลดความอ้วน

    Nice job, it’s a great post. The info is good to know! Thank you.

  • http://www.allinklwith.us/acapella-102/?sort=postusername&order=asc nulled scriptz, forum scriptz, warez

    nulled scriptz, forum scriptz, warez…

    [...]Prateek Dayal » Why Shelfari.com sucks so much![...]…

  • http://www.buyfacebookfansbuyfacebookfansbuyfacebookfansbuyfansbuyfans.info/ Buy Facebook Fans

    Sources…

    [...]here are some links to sites that we link to because we think they are worth visiting[...]…

  • http://nulledscripts.es/cms/page/4/ Nulled Scripts – Download Free Full Nulled Scripts, SEO Tools, WordPress and Joomla Premium Templates, Premium Plugin, CMS Scripts.

    Nulled Scripts – Download Free Full Nulled Scripts, SEO Tools, WordPress and Joomla Premium Templates, Premium Plugin, CMS Scripts….

    [...]Prateek Dayal » Why Shelfari.com sucks so much![...]…

blog comments powered by Disqus