Comments on: Who is the best critique for your startup? http://www.prateekdayal.net/2008/05/21/who-is-the-best-critique-for-your-startup/ Ruby on Rails + Web 2.0 + Life :) Tue, 07 Feb 2012 06:59:00 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.0.1 By: Puneeth http://www.prateekdayal.net/2008/05/21/who-is-the-best-critique-for-your-startup/comment-page-2/#comment-2956 Puneeth Thu, 26 Jun 2008 05:42:24 +0000 http://prateekdayal.net/blog/?p=72#comment-2956 Digging through. Should reach you in few minutes Digging through. Should reach you in few minutes

]]> By: Puneeth http://www.prateekdayal.net/2008/05/21/who-is-the-best-critique-for-your-startup/comment-page-2/#comment-33562 Puneeth Thu, 26 Jun 2008 05:42:00 +0000 http://prateekdayal.net/blog/?p=72#comment-33562 Digging through. Should reach you in few minutes Digging through. Should reach you in few minutes

]]> By: Prateek Dayal http://www.prateekdayal.net/2008/05/21/who-is-the-best-critique-for-your-startup/comment-page-2/#comment-2955 Prateek Dayal Thu, 26 Jun 2008 05:33:36 +0000 http://prateekdayal.net/blog/?p=72#comment-2955 Cool .. no issues. If you still have that email I would like to go over it. The one with feedback on Muziboo. Cool .. no issues. If you still have that email I would like to go over it. The one with feedback on Muziboo.

]]> By: Prateek Dayal http://www.prateekdayal.net/2008/05/21/who-is-the-best-critique-for-your-startup/comment-page-2/#comment-33561 Prateek Dayal Thu, 26 Jun 2008 05:33:00 +0000 http://prateekdayal.net/blog/?p=72#comment-33561 Cool .. no issues. If you still have that email I would like to go over it. The one with feedback on Muziboo. Cool .. no issues. If you still have that email I would like to go over it. The one with feedback on Muziboo.

]]> By: Puneeth http://www.prateekdayal.net/2008/05/21/who-is-the-best-critique-for-your-startup/comment-page-2/#comment-2954 Puneeth Thu, 26 Jun 2008 05:27:26 +0000 http://prateekdayal.net/blog/?p=72#comment-2954 Hey Prateek, All I said was it was an oversight that you did not receive. I was the one co-ordinating with the review committee. We will definitely use this feedback for the upcoming event and will be on the top of my list of TODOs. Regarding, the consumer segment - yes it is too easy to start in the sense that you don't need to invest too much money in getting started. Most of them had based their business model around Ads. Will catch up with you at one of the OCC or StartupSaturdays. Meanwhile, keep your feedback/comments flowing - good or bad. They will help us plan better next time around. ~Puneeth Hey Prateek,
All I said was it was an oversight that you did not receive. I was the one co-ordinating with the review committee. We will definitely use this feedback for the upcoming event and will be on the top of my list of TODOs.

Regarding, the consumer segment – yes it is too easy to start in the sense that you don’t need to invest too much money in getting started. Most of them had based their business model around Ads.

Will catch up with you at one of the OCC or StartupSaturdays.

Meanwhile, keep your feedback/comments flowing – good or bad. They will help us plan better next time around.

~Puneeth

]]> By: Puneeth http://www.prateekdayal.net/2008/05/21/who-is-the-best-critique-for-your-startup/comment-page-2/#comment-33560 Puneeth Thu, 26 Jun 2008 05:27:00 +0000 http://prateekdayal.net/blog/?p=72#comment-33560 Hey Prateek, All I said was it was an oversight that you did not receive. I was the one co-ordinating with the review committee. We will definitely use this feedback for the upcoming event and will be on the top of my list of TODOs. Regarding, the consumer segment - yes it is too easy to start in the sense that you don't need to invest too much money in getting started. Most of them had based their business model around Ads. Will catch up with you at one of the OCC or StartupSaturdays. Meanwhile, keep your feedback/comments flowing - good or bad. They will help us plan better next time around. ~Puneeth Hey Prateek,
All I said was it was an oversight that you did not receive. I was the one co-ordinating with the review committee. We will definitely use this feedback for the upcoming event and will be on the top of my list of TODOs.

Regarding, the consumer segment – yes it is too easy to start in the sense that you don’t need to invest too much money in getting started. Most of them had based their business model around Ads.

Will catch up with you at one of the OCC or StartupSaturdays.

Meanwhile, keep your feedback/comments flowing – good or bad. They will help us plan better next time around.

~Puneeth

]]> By: Prateek Dayal http://www.prateekdayal.net/2008/05/21/who-is-the-best-critique-for-your-startup/comment-page-2/#comment-2953 Prateek Dayal Thu, 26 Jun 2008 05:13:45 +0000 http://prateekdayal.net/blog/?p=72#comment-2953 In fact I had posted a comment to the blog entry written here http://blog.headstart.in/?p=13 I had written that I have not received any email regarding the results when in fact around 4th Jan, we got an email asking for some more details on Muziboo. I got no response to the comment and now my comment is gone from the post. Also if you notice Shaurabh is the one who has written that blog post. In the interest of free speech, deleting comments (unless they use explicit language) is not a great idea In fact I had posted a comment to the blog entry written here

http://blog.headstart.in/?p=13

I had written that I have not received any email regarding the results when in fact around 4th Jan, we got an email asking for some more details on Muziboo.

I got no response to the comment and now my comment is gone from the post. Also if you notice Shaurabh is the one who has written that blog post.

In the interest of free speech, deleting comments (unless they use explicit language) is not a great idea

]]> By: Prateek Dayal http://www.prateekdayal.net/2008/05/21/who-is-the-best-critique-for-your-startup/comment-page-2/#comment-33559 Prateek Dayal Thu, 26 Jun 2008 05:13:00 +0000 http://prateekdayal.net/blog/?p=72#comment-33559 In fact I had posted a comment to the blog entry written here http://blog.headstart.in/?p=13 I had written that I have not received any email regarding the results when in fact around 4th Jan, we got an email asking for some more details on Muziboo. I got no response to the comment and now my comment is gone from the post. Also if you notice Shaurabh is the one who has written that blog post. In the interest of free speech, deleting comments (unless they use explicit language) is not a great idea In fact I had posted a comment to the blog entry written here

http://blog.headstart.in/?p=13

I had written that I have not received any email regarding the results when in fact around 4th Jan, we got an email asking for some more details on Muziboo.

I got no response to the comment and now my comment is gone from the post. Also if you notice Shaurabh is the one who has written that blog post.

In the interest of free speech, deleting comments (unless they use explicit language) is not a great idea

]]> By: Prateek Dayal http://www.prateekdayal.net/2008/05/21/who-is-the-best-critique-for-your-startup/comment-page-1/#comment-2952 Prateek Dayal Thu, 26 Jun 2008 05:05:36 +0000 http://prateekdayal.net/blog/?p=72#comment-2952 Hi Puneeth Ok .. .here is the thing. I hope headstart team can use the feedback. Names mentioned here are not to point fingers at anyone. On Jan 15th we sent an email to check for results to support@headstart.in and the mail bounced back.This was a day before the event. I had also emailed on the OCC list (replying to your email) asking if anyone else knows about the results. I think my mail should still be in the archives. No reply whatsoever. Then I got an email on Jan 16th about "VC Networking at HeadStart on 19th Jan". We still did not know if we had made it or not. This mail therefore was all the more confusing. The email listed Shaurabh Bharti and Ashish Kulkarni as contact people. We sent an email asking if we are in or not but then I also called about Sharuabh and he did not know either and told me he will call me back. After that we got an email saying that we are not in and this is a separate thing that we can participate in. All in all it was quite confusing. I am not saying the spirit was not there, but there was lot of chaos. <i>given that Consumer segment was the one which got huge number of nominations [no points for guessing why ;) ].</i> In fact I would like to know why you think there are no points for guessing. Too easy to start? Hi Puneeth

Ok .. .here is the thing. I hope headstart team can use the feedback. Names mentioned here are not to point fingers at anyone.

On Jan 15th we sent an email to check for results to support@headstart.in and the mail bounced back.This was a day before the event. I had also emailed on the OCC list (replying to your email) asking if anyone else knows about the results. I think my mail should still be in the archives. No reply whatsoever.

Then I got an email on Jan 16th about “VC Networking at HeadStart on 19th Jan”. We still did not know if we had made it or not. This mail therefore was all the more confusing. The email listed Shaurabh Bharti and Ashish Kulkarni as contact people. We sent an email asking if we are in or not but then I also called about Sharuabh and he did not know either and told me he will call me back. After that we got an email saying that we are not in and this is a separate thing that we can participate in.

All in all it was quite confusing. I am not saying the spirit was not there, but there was lot of chaos.

given that Consumer segment was the one which got huge number of nominations [no points for guessing why ;) ].

In fact I would like to know why you think there are no points for guessing. Too easy to start?

]]> By: Prateek Dayal http://www.prateekdayal.net/2008/05/21/who-is-the-best-critique-for-your-startup/comment-page-1/#comment-33558 Prateek Dayal Thu, 26 Jun 2008 05:05:00 +0000 http://prateekdayal.net/blog/?p=72#comment-33558 Hi Puneeth Ok .. .here is the thing. I hope headstart team can use the feedback. Names mentioned here are not to point fingers at anyone. On Jan 15th we sent an email to check for results to support@headstart.in and the mail bounced back.This was a day before the event. I had also emailed on the OCC list (replying to your email) asking if anyone else knows about the results. I think my mail should still be in the archives. No reply whatsoever. Then I got an email on Jan 16th about "VC Networking at HeadStart on 19th Jan". We still did not know if we had made it or not. This mail therefore was all the more confusing. The email listed Shaurabh Bharti and Ashish Kulkarni as contact people. We sent an email asking if we are in or not but then I also called about Sharuabh and he did not know either and told me he will call me back. After that we got an email saying that we are not in and this is a separate thing that we can participate in. All in all it was quite confusing. I am not saying the spirit was not there, but there was lot of chaos. <i>given that Consumer segment was the one which got huge number of nominations [no points for guessing why ;) ].</i> In fact I would like to know why you think there are no points for guessing. Too easy to start? Hi Puneeth

Ok .. .here is the thing. I hope headstart team can use the feedback. Names mentioned here are not to point fingers at anyone.

On Jan 15th we sent an email to check for results to support@headstart.in and the mail bounced back.This was a day before the event. I had also emailed on the OCC list (replying to your email) asking if anyone else knows about the results. I think my mail should still be in the archives. No reply whatsoever.

Then I got an email on Jan 16th about “VC Networking at HeadStart on 19th Jan”. We still did not know if we had made it or not. This mail therefore was all the more confusing. The email listed Shaurabh Bharti and Ashish Kulkarni as contact people. We sent an email asking if we are in or not but then I also called about Sharuabh and he did not know either and told me he will call me back. After that we got an email saying that we are not in and this is a separate thing that we can participate in.

All in all it was quite confusing. I am not saying the spirit was not there, but there was lot of chaos.

given that Consumer segment was the one which got huge number of nominations [no points for guessing why ;) ].

In fact I would like to know why you think there are no points for guessing. Too easy to start?

]]>